Beard argued that the framers of the constitution were interested more in furthering their own economic interests than in creating a truly representative government. The modern economic history of the constitution indicates that charles beard's economic interpretation has not yet been refuted the issues, in fact, have not been heretofore tested earlier historical studies did not have the benefit of modern economic methodology and systematic statistical analysis. Some 45 years ago charles a beard propounded an economic interpretation of the constitution—an interpretation which submitted that the constitution was essentially (that is a crucial word) an economic document—and that it was carried through the convention and the state ratifying conventions by interested economic groups for economic reasons.
In his piercing introduction to an economic interpretation the author wrote that 'whoever leaves economic pressures out of history or out of discussion of public questions is in mortal peril of substituting mythology for reality' it was beard's view that the founding fathers, especially madison. Author: charles a beard isbn: 9780486140452 publisher: dover publications in this famous study, the author turned the hagiography of many earlier dover publications march 2012 336 pages isbn 9780486140452 read online, or download in secure epub title: an economic interpretation of the. Beard published an economic interpretation of the constitution in 1913, while still in residence at columbia it became his best known and most controversial book it became his best known and most controversial book. Until charles a beard published his an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states (1913), the standard account of the founding era was that the framers acted out of idealism - a disinterested, public-regarding impulse to promote democratic ideals for which the revolution was fought and the american republic was founded.
Should an economic interpretation of the constitution be regarded as a relic of the progressive theory of economic determinism, or has revisionist scholarship saved the beard thesis from extinction economic theory aside, it is hard to see how the mind and spirit of charles beard, who in his own distinctive way was a nationalist, nativist, and. Abstract a century after it was first published, charles a beard's an economic interpretation of the constitution remains a significant and controversial part of constitutional scholarship and history. One hundred years later, an economic interpretation continues to stand the test of time, raising fascinating deconstruction of the motivations of the delegates to the constitutional convention beard carries his thesis that the us constitution did not originate out of high-minded, disinterested. Beard's 1913 book, an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states, has been viewed as the beginning of what became known as the history wars, which challenged many of the traditional concepts of teaching and interpreting american history. In 1913, beard, then on the faculty of columbia university, published an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states (free press, $295) it was a scholar's monograph, directed to historians and political scientists.
Charles beard thesis : writing service but charles beard changed the way reform-minded leaders thought about the constitution in an economic interpretation of the constitution, professor beard argued that it wasn't political philosophy, or idealism which influenced the founding fathers, but selfish economic greed. Since it was first published in 1913, charles a beard's an economic interpretation of the constitution has been a lightning rod of controversy for constitutional scholars and historians yet to understand better how and why beard wrote an economic interpretation of the constitution, one. Beard expanded upon becker's thesis, in terms of class conflict, in an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states (1913) and an economic interpretation of jeffersonian democracy (1915) to beard, the constitution was a counter-revolution, set up by rich bondholders (personalty since bonds were personal property), in. 4 beard, an economic interpretation, pp 16-18 5 although we believe this paragraph accurately reflects charles beard's thesis, other scholars may not agree beard's an economic interpretation is confusing because he uses terms imprecisely, continuously interchanging economic interest with.
The first historian to challenge the motives of the founders was charles beard in an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states (1913) in this landmark book, beard, a professor of history at columbia university, argued that the constitution was an economic document drawn with superb skill by men whose property. Charles beard and the constitution in 1913 there appeared a book which caused more than a ripple of interest in both academic and nonacademic circles from the moment of its debut, an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states by charles a beard was a subject of heated controversy. I charles beard: an economic interpretation of the constitution, 1913, enormously influential 1 tested beard's major hypotheses regarding the origins and ratification of the constitution by subjecting the economic interests of the delegates to the federal and state constitutional conventions to a close. Economic interpretation the values have an important economic interpretation: if the right hand side of constraint i is increased by , then the optimum objective value increases by approximately. The thesis of charles beard's an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states presently enjoys approximately the same status as alchemy and medical.
An economic interpretation of the constitution was written instead, commentators and critics alike have frequently detached beard's text from its historical context. B beard's thesis has been a springboard for such views as the belief that the constitution was an effort of conservatives to preserve economic interests at the expense of the principles of the revolution, and not as an effort to pr eserve the ideal s. When i was in college, beard's classic an economic interpretation of the constitution was on the required reading list for a bachelor's degree in political science it is still a classic work, but some of its arguments have been disputed by later prominent historians beard looked at everything through the.
Charles beard economic interpretation constitution thesis for almost 40 years, beard's interpretation was accepted and people believed that the founding fathers had written the constitution out of selfish interests instead of idealism. Beard's an economic interpretation of the constitution in 5 minutes yet the argument continues recent studies have sought to defend the economic interpretation of the constitution, while modifying or expanding on certain aspects of the original beard thesis. An economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states is a 1913 book by american historian charles a beardit argues that the structure of the constitution of the united states was motivated primarily by the personal financial interests of the founding fathers.
Charles a beard presented seemingly irrefutable proof of the antidemocratic and conservative foundations of american national government in an economic interpretation of the constitution beard's thesis was that the politics of the 1780s were dominated by a. 320 the journal of politics [ vol 19 the brown volume, a chapter by chapter assault on beard's classic enonomic interpretation, is a short book but an extra. Beard presented an innovative monograph in 1913 when his book, an economic interpretation of the constitution of the united states, was first printed by the free press of new york, new york.